I'm reading a truly wonderful book written by the
poet Mary Ruefle. By wonderful I mean intelligent and engaging, humble and
erudite. It is a collection of lectures titled Madness, Rack, and Honey
(Wave Press 2012).
In the lecture she calls "Fear," she asks
us to consider John Berger's "succinct and frightening
sentence."
"Everywhere these days more and more people
knock their heads against the fact that the future of our planet, and what it
will offer or deny to its inhabitants, is being decided by boards of men who
control more money than all the governments in the world, who never stand for
election, and whose sole criterion for every decision they take is whether or
not it increases or is prone to increase Profit."
My first encounters with questioning the costs and
benefits of Profit came during my high school years, during the 1970s, but not in high school
itself. These encounters came at church.
One Sunday, Brother Moody, also known as Dr. Moody,
a professor of agricultural economics at Arizona State University--the
university down the street from my high school I would later
attend--cautioned against "too much profit." Dr. Moody warned
that this pursuit was harmful to the Economy, writ large.
Meanwhile, during my zero-hour seminary classes,
held across the street from my high school in a church-owned building, I was
trying to understand what it was Jesus was trying to teach us.
Among the several lessons that have stuck with me was a philosophical question that went something like this: What is a man
profited if he gains the whole world but loses his own soul?
Right now, extreme efforts are underway by a
consortium of two of the world's largest multi-national mining corporations--London-based
Anglo-American and Canada's Northern Dynasty--to get US government-approval to
build the Pebble Mine.
This mine would be one of the world's largest
open-pit copper, gold, and molybdenum mines and would be located at the headwaters of Bristol Bay--at the Kvichak and Nushagak Rivers--one of the most
productive wild salmon habitats in the world.
Not only is the area environmentally sensitive, it
is seismically sensitive, and would include the world's largest earthen dam, a
dam which scientists claim may not withstand a seismic event of a magnitude of
the 1964 Anchorage earthquake. What are we willing to risk for Profit?
Daily, it seems, I ask myself if today is the day
we humans will snap out from under the spell of the large and small Profits
that cause all of us to put our ecosystems--and their sustainability--at
risk. It seems that day will always be tomorrow, and for someone else.
Here in Northern California, we've made life all
but unsustainable for salmon and steelhead in the once-prolific Russian River,
one minor--or major--diversion of water at a time. Globally, our minor and major
actions have radically, perhaps irreversibly, altered our atmosphere.
So why the photograph of Mono Lake? To remind
myself that Soul sometimes prevails over Profit, and how it is done.
Margaret Mead: "Never doubt that a small group
of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world: indeed, it's the only
thing that ever has."
